For over a decade, social media was the darling of marketing teams everywhere—a new playground promising reach, engagement, and ROI. But now, a surprising shift is underway: marketers are signaling a pullback on social media spending. So what changed?
According to Bob Hoffman
MarketingWeek surveyed over 3,500 marketing professionals. The question they asked was, “What is the most overrated marketing skill?” For the third consecutive year, the marketers picked social media as the most overrated skill.
According to the Harvard Business Review, marketers’ spending on social media dropped from 17% in the spring of 2023 to 11% in the spring of 2024, the lowest spending level in seven years.
According to HBR, here are some of the reasons why spending on social has dropped:
- Clutter
- “Social media fatigue”
- “Social media hasn’t delivered desired gains.”
- Attribution problems
Nonetheless, when asked to estimate what they’ll spend on social media in 5 years, marketers projected they’d spend 66% more. This makes absolutely no sense, but that’s marketers for you.
1. Diminishing Organic Reach
Once upon a time, posting on social media meant your followers would see it. Not anymore. Algorithms have tightened, especially on platforms like Facebook and Instagram. Brands now have to pay to reach even their followers, and the value of organic content continues to erode.
2. Ad Fatigue and Banner Blindness
Users are bombarded with ads, sponsored posts, and influencer content. The result? Ad fatigue. People scroll right past brand content without engaging. And with everyone chasing trends, much of the content feels repetitive and inauthentic.
3. Questionable ROI
While tracking likes, shares, and views is easy, those metrics often don’t translate to sales. Many marketers are asking tough questions: What are we getting from this spend? And often, the answer is: Not much. Attribution remains murky, and the path from scroll to sale is rarely direct.
4. Brand Safety Concerns
Social media has become a hotbed for misinformation, toxicity, and divisive content. Brands don’t want to risk appearing next to controversial posts or on platforms that can’t—or won’t—moderate harmful content. The reputational risk is real.
5. Rising Costs
As more brands piled into social media, ad costs skyrocketed. CPCs and CPMs on platforms like Meta and TikTok have risen sharply, while performance has plateaued or declined. For many marketers, those dollars are now better spent elsewhere.
6. Privacy Changes and Targeting Limitations
Apple’s iOS privacy changes and growing consumer concerns about data tracking have made precise targeting harder. The days of hyper-targeted, data-rich campaigns are fading, and many marketers are feeling the impact in declining ad efficiency.
7. Influencer Overload
Influencer marketing once felt fresh and personal. Today, it can feel forced and transactional. Consumers are increasingly skeptical of influencers who promote a new brand every week, and influencer fatigue is setting in.
8. Shifting Consumer Behavior
Younger users are still on social platforms, but their use is changing. They’re spending more time on private or semi-private platforms (like Discord or Telegram), where traditional marketing can’t reach them. Plus, they’re tuning into creators and communities—not brands.
9. New Focus on Owned Channels
With all the uncertainty, many brands return to what they can control: websites, email lists, apps, and content hubs. These channels offer better data, stronger connections, and long-term value.
What Comes Next?
Social media isn’t disappearing—it’s just not the sure bet it once was. Marketers are getting smarter about how and where they spend. That means less reliance on social media for broad brand-building and more focus on meaningful, measurable marketing.
Discover more from New Media and Marketing
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
