Let’s be honest: your customers don’t want to have a relationship with your brand. They want their laundry detergent to work. They want their coffee to taste good. They want their phone not to die at 3 pm. Somewhere along the way, brands got it into their heads that consumers were sitting around, desperately hoping to forge a deep, meaningful connection with the company that makes their toothpaste. Marketing teams started obsessing over “brand love” and “emotional engagement,” as if people were going to put the logo on their vision boards and write heartfelt letters about how much the brand means to them.
Here’s the reality: consumers’ top priorities are value, quality, and price.
That’s it. That’s the list.
The Relationship Myth
The marketing industry has spent the last decade pushing this narrative that every brand needs to be a lifestyle, a community, a movement. Social media managers are instructed to have a “brand voice” that’s witty and relatable. Companies launch campaigns asking customers to share their stories and become “brand ambassadors.”
But walk into any store and watch what actually happens. People scan the shelf, check the price, maybe read a label, and make a decision in about eight seconds. They’re not having an emotional moment. They’re buying dish soap.
The uncomfortable truth is that most brands are indistinguishable to consumers. Unless you’re selling something truly distinctive—or you’re literally the only option—people will switch to whatever offers them better value without a second thought.
What Consumers Actually Want
Quality: Does your product do what it’s supposed to do? Does it last? Does it work as advertised? This is table stakes, not a bonus feature.
Value: Am I getting what I pay for? Is this worth the money? Notice that “cheap” and “value” aren’t the same thing. People will pay more if they believe they’re receiving proportional quality.
Price: Can I afford this? Is there a comparable alternative for less? Price matters to everyone, regardless of income level. Acting like it doesn’t is tone-deaf.
These three factors drive the vast majority of purchasing decisions. Not your clever tweet. Not your inspirational brand story. Not your purpose-driven mission statement that looks great on the About Us page.
The Exception, Not the Rule
Yes, there are exceptions. Some brands genuinely do build passionate communities—think Apple, Patagonia, or Harley-Davidson. But these are outliers, and their success comes from genuinely distinctive products and experiences, not just marketing fluff.
For every brand that successfully builds loyalty through emotional connection, hundreds waste resources trying to manufacture intimacy with consumers who don’t care. Your mayonnaise doesn’t need a personality.
What Brands Should Do Instead
Get the fundamentals right. Make a good product. Price it fairly. Make it easy to buy. Deliver on your promises. This isn’t sexy, but it works.
Stop forcing the connection. If customers want to engage with you on social media, great. But don’t mistake a few likes and comments for a deep relationship. Most people following your brand account are just hoping for discount codes.
Respect people’s time and intelligence. Nobody wants to watch a three-minute video explaining your brand philosophy before they can find out how much the thing costs. Put the important information up front.
Be reliable, not relatable. Consumers don’t need you to understand their lifestyle. They need you to know what they’re trying to accomplish with your product and help them achieve it.
Compete on what matters. If you can’t win on quality, value, or price, figure out why—then fix it. Don’t try to distract from mediocre products with aspirational marketing.
The Bottom Line
Consumers aren’t looking for more relationships. They have friends, family, and community for that. What they’re looking for when they interact with your brand is simple: a good product, reasonably priced, that solves their problem.
That might not sound as exciting as building a movement or creating brand love. But it’s what actually drives business results. The sooner brands accept that most customers want a straightforward transaction—good stuff for a fair price—the sooner they can stop wasting money on forced authenticity and start investing in what actually matters.
Your brand doesn’t need to be their friend. It just needs not to waste their time or money.
Discover more from New Media and Marketing
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
