Close your eyes and picture flight school with a teacher who’s never been in an actual plane. Imagine learning surgery from someone who has never dissected a human being. Crazy, right? Universities do the exact same thing with students every single day. They employ PhD’s with spotless academic backgrounds to lecture students on marketing–despite the fact that they may have never built a brand from the ground up. They may have never shipped a successful product. They may have never managed an advertising budget. Or in some cases, they may have never been accountable for 1 cent of revenue. What’s the point? Marketing isn’t philosophy. It’s not English. It’s not one of those majors where theories can go untouched for centuries. Marketing is a battlefield.
The real economy. Customers. Market share. Profit. And the marketplace evolves nearly daily. Google updates its algorithms. Artificial intelligence is rewriting how content is created. Consumers behave differently. Old platforms die. New ones emerge. The marketplace doesn’t care how many papers you’ve had peer-reviewed and published. It only cares if your campaign moved the needle.
Universities like to boast that PhDs are experts because they know the science of marketing. Ok. Knowing all that consumer psychology, statistics, research methods, and marketing theory is fantastic. But theory is just a map. Real-world experience is the territory. Give a professor an hour, and they can discuss brand positioning. Give a marketer who has spent two decades positioning brands an hour, and they can tell you why the positioning failed. They can explain how customers really reacted. What the data told us. How leadership panicked. And what actually worked.
Then there are the ones on social media who act like they are marketing experts. Some even set up agencies. You know who they are, and yet people treat them like royalty.
A professor might help you make grade, but someone with business experience will help you understand the REAL world and help students ace job interviews and crush their careers.
Most marketing professors have never had to justify a half-million-dollar media buy to a company’s CEO. They’ve never watched the numbers hemorrhage because a campaign missed the target. They’ve never had to let an agency go. Pivot a product launch. Or convince angry shareholders that “things will be better next quarter.” Professors mess up on paper. Outcomes don’t matter. Marketers’ failures are public (and educational).
What you won’t learn from a professor you can’t learn from textbooks. Most universities boast about how many articles their professors have published. (Employers don’t care how many articles their employees read.) Employers ask about experience. Can you create leads? Build brands? Interpret data? Drive sales? Help businesses solve problems? What are you noticing? Academic journals are not mentioned.
Ever heard a hiring manager ask, “How many academic journals has your professor published?” Yeah, me neither. Ironic, right? Schools of business want to prepare students for the business world. But employ faculty who have spent their careers… teaching and researching.
Why would you want to learn about the marketplace from people who have never had to compete within it? Imagine if medical schools were staffed with professors who had never seen a real patient. Or engineering schools hired faculty who had never designed anything. Or law schools didn’t care if their students ever worked with practicing attorneys.
So what makes marketing any different? Successful business schools require faculty who are scholars AND experienced professionals. Students should learn marketing theory from researchers. And learn how to apply it from marketers who have been in the trenches running campaigns. Learn branding from talented experts who have built valuable brands. Learn digital marketing from people who still look at benchmarks, buy media, interpret Google data, and adapt to AI – not someone who thinks Facebook is a new newspaper.
Education is important. Real-world experience is invaluable. The market never gives you a participation award. It’s the stern professor that grades whether your ideas are worthy of merit—or if they should just fade away. Maybe universities should allow the market to have a say in who teaches in their classrooms. Marketing students don’t need professors who know marketing. They need professors who have been knocked down by it and got back up.
Discover more from New Media and Marketing
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
